The Usual Suspects: Does your Loyalty Program really need points and tiers?

Points and three tiers is a common loyalty program design. We tested when it fits and when another design does the job better.

Ellipsis Perspective published 18th November 2026.  From time to time, we come together as a business to debate and challenge our own thinking.

If you ask someone randomly what a loyalty program looks like, they will probably say it has points and tiers. We have designed numerous programs with this structure: it is easy to explain to your board , customers and staff recognise it and you don’t have to teach the market anything new.

But recently our projects have taken us to programs with no points, programs with no tiers, and programs where points and tiers do different jobs.

So, we challenged the structure;  is this really the ultimate design or is it  an easy default? We benchmarked  the structure  against examples from retail, services, financial services and travel. We found two conditions that make points and tiers the right choice, the alternatives when those conditions are missing, and the checks we now run at the start of a design project.

Why the default exists

When a structure is this widely understood, it becomes the starting point for many design conversations, and it can be chosen before anyone has asked whether it fits.

In the session we noticed that businesses earlier in their loyalty journey tend to land on points and tiers, while those with mature data and clear relevance strategies more often move to something different, because they have the capability to run it.

Matching design to capability is sensible risk management, but capability alone should not decide the design. Our design criteria start with which customers a business wants to engage, which behaviours it wants from them, and what it can afford to reward. Those answers should shape the program, rather than have it fit a shape already chosen.

Points depend on frequency

Points work by storing and accumulating customer value, but saving only works  if they shop often enough to build a balance worth having.

Think about a customer who buys her child’s boots from the same retailer every year. She is genuinely loyal, but she will never reach a top tier, and the points she earns in a year rarely add up to much. To the retailer she looks like a low spender, so she gets no recognition at all.

Insurance is another example of the challenge presented by infrequency. Customers buy a policy once a year and might only ever hold one or two, so a points balance never really gets going. For an insurer, instant rewards make more sense; otherwise, customers would wait far too long to see any value. The same goes for any category where people don’t buy very often.

Even with enough frequency, the reward must be worth collecting for. The rewards customers crave  most are hedonic, the treats and travel they wouldn’t justify out of the household budget, while rewards that feel virtuous attract far less interest. Charities, for example, often expect a steady flow of donated points each year, yet they receive very little, under 1% of points across the board1. Customers, it turns out, want to spend their points on themselves.

Tiers depend on aspiration

Whether customers will be engaged by  tiers comes down to two things: how much the reward is worth, and how hard it is to earn. These are the two axes of the reward value and distance 2x2 we use in design.

When the reward is small, it needs to be frequent and easy to get, so adding a tier only makes it harder and works against the program. Nobody cares about platinum status at a cafe when the reward is a free coffee. When the reward is large, customers are willing to work for it. A family holiday can be worth two years of effort and several tiers along the way, particularly when those tiers bring lounge access and early boarding on the journey there. Academic work that has tested tier propositions points the same way2.

Tiers also only influence a fairly narrow part of the base. Customers who watch their distance to the next tier are already in the top two, and while platinum members notice and respond when they are downgraded, bronze members rarely react to tier changes at all. In practice, a tier structure is a program for the top of the base, and it is worth costing as one.

A tier also needs something meaningful to offer at each level. Airlines can fence off a lounge or a priority queue at relatively low cost, but a grocer would need a serious operation to offer anything equivalent, and its customers would care little. Nobody buys more groceries than they need just to chase status. That’s why we ask about assets available for rewards early in a project. Knowing what a business can genuinely offer at each level often points quickly to the right design.

A tier adds a second behaviour

Whether anyone calls it that or not, a tier introduces a second currency. Points reward one behaviour and status rewards another, something the airlines learned first. Banks were issuing large volumes of points on credit cards, and many of the people collecting them weren’t flying, so the airlines added status credits that only flyers could earn. That gave them two currencies for two behaviours: buying and flying.

We see the same split in financial services, where points reward specific actions and tiers reward how much of the main relationship a customer holds, such as the number of products. In one large scale Australian program , customers don’t spend enough on any single product to earn many points, so the tiers do the work of moving them to a second product.

Tiers are most effective  when they reinforce a behaviour that points don’t already reward. When both reward the same behaviour, the business ends up paying twice, and the tier mostly rewards customers who would have earned the most points anyway because they already spend the most.

Affordability is the other constraint. In one retail program we reviewed, the base earn rate was already high, so funding tier benefits would have meant either cutting the earn rate or paying the same top customers twice. Tiers should deliver additional incremental returns to justify their costs.

Alternative program structures

Several designs sit outside points and three tiers, and each suits a different set of conditions.

  • Tiers only. Status unlocks through activity and there is no redeemable currency. Booking.com's Genius levels work this way, with discounts attached to each level3. We designed a program like this for a business that wanted to encourage healthy behaviour but had no budget line to pay for it. Points have no cash value and exist only to unlock tiers, and the tiers carry the benefits, so the program rewards the behaviour the business cares about without paying for it directly.

  • Points with a low base rate and a large bonus pool with no tiers. Some grocery programs pay a small base rate and use targeted bonus points to change behaviour. In habit categories, people tend to shop on autopilot, and bonus points are how a retailer gets noticed. The bonus pool is worth modelling carefully. Setting aside a round-number share of the points pool is a common starting assumption, and real below-the-line spend rarely behaves that neatly.

  • Instant rewards. These suit categories with infrequent purchases, where points cannot accumulate.

  • Paid membership. The value has to be obvious from day one. Consumers expect at least 150% return on the subscription fee4. Costco has run on a membership model from the start, but elsewhere paid memberships haven’t always covered their cost. The members who pay are usually the ones who already expect to get their fee back, so the program may simply be capturing spend that would have happened anyway. Paying members also rarely say they dislike a program they have paid for, so high satisfaction scores can flatter the design. The more useful question is how much of their spend is incremental.

  • Points in place of cashback. Yello moved to points after running cashback. Cashback delivers its value in the transaction, whereas points ask customers to work toward something over time, reinforcing a relationship over time.

Category and customer shape the answer

Before any design choice is made, the category sets a baseline level of engagement. Categories people naturally care about, like pets and babies, give a program a head start, while categories with little natural interest, such as salt, need stronger mechanics to build engagement. Grocery sits somewhere in between. It runs on habit, so a program has to find ways to interrupt it.

B2B programs tend to fall into two groups. In many, the business owner receives the reward personally, which turns company spend into a source of tax-free personal benefit, and fuel cards and some business rewards programs work this way. Once a company is big enough to have a procurement function, though, the gatekeepers stop staff choosing suppliers based on rewards, and personal rewards lose their influence. Employee recognition schemes are a separate group again. They are common, and they work best when the company is visibly committed to them.

A program launched alongside every existing promotion adds cost without taking any away. If a retailer keeps all of its current above-the-line offers and then adds a loyalty program on top, it doubles up on costs.. Before launch, decide which existing offers the program will replace.

Operations carry more weight than design

The programs we see performing well tend to combine a functional design with strong operations. The design is sound, but the results come from execution , from promotion planning that is built into the wider business, and from a team that can run the program week in, week out. In our experience, how a program is run influences results as much as how it is designed.

Time spent refining the finer points of a design tends to pay back less than time spent building the team and capability to run it. A well-resourced team will get more out of a straightforward design than a sophisticated one can deliver on its own, so investment in the people who operate a program is usually where the returns are.

Across our work, we have seen how much the right technology lifts a design. When the platform, the below-the-line budget and the team are in place, even a simple program can deliver strong results. That’s why we emphasise feasibility of execution in the design, looking at the technology, budget and people a business has to run the program, and modelling below-the-line costs on what they will be in practice.

Seven checks before choosing a design

The discussion gave us a set of checks to at the start of a program design project. .

  1. Frequency. Customers need enough visits or purchases to accumulate points. Where they do not, consider instant rewards.

  2. Reward value. The reward has to be worth the effort. Hedonic rewards outperform virtuous ones.

  3. Distance. Tiers suit valuable rewards that take effort. Low-value rewards need to be easy and frequent.

  4. Second behaviour. Name the behaviour the tiers will reinforce that points do not. If there is none, tiers add cost only.

  5. Assets and funding. Identify what you can offer at each tier, what it costs to deliver, and where the money comes from.

  6. Operations. Confirm you can run the design, including technology, below-the-line execution and team capability.

  7. Category. Check the natural engagement of the category and whether habit means the program needs bonus mechanics to get noticed.

Starting from the conditions

Points with three tiers will stay the right choice for many businesses. It suits programs with frequent purchases, rewards worth working for, something meaningful to offer at each tier and a team that can run it. But next time you reach for the familiar setup, it may be worth asking a few questions first. Do your customers buy often enough to build a balance? Is there something worth offering at each tier? Do you have the technology and team to run it every week? If the answers are yes, points and tiers will serve you well. If not, there may be a design that works harder for your business.

We are Ellipsis, The Loyalty Experts®. We help you measure, manage and grow customer loyalty. We're here to help, please get in touch.

References:

  1. Share of points donated to charity (under 1%). Source to be confirmed before publication.

  2. Academic research testing tier propositions, reward value and effort. Source to be identified.

  3. Booking.com Genius program structure. Confirm against Booking.com's own published program terms.

  4. Julien Boudet, Jess Huang and Ryter von Difloe, “Coping with the big switch: How paid loyalty programs can help bring consumers back to your brand”, McKinsey & Company, October 2020. Consumers expect at least a 150% return on a paid program’s fee.