The myth: If a customer has gone quiet, a targeted offer will bring them back, and that's worth doing.
By Tim Tyler, 29 September 2026
Re-activation campaigns are a staple of loyalty marketing calendars. They feel productive since you have a defined audience, a clear objective, and a measurable outcome (did they transact again?). The problem is that the economics rarely work, and nobody checks.
Customers who have genuinely lapsed - no transactions in twelve or eighteen months - have usually lapsed for a reason. They moved away. They found a better alternative. The category is no longer relevant to their life stage. In most cases, the program didn't cause the lapse, and a program offer won't reverse it.
To quote the Customer Centric superstar Mr Fader: “There’s a reason why most 'at-risk' customers are at risk: they’re bad customers. They’re flighty, fickle, expensive to deal with, and offer little upside. Many don’t even think of themselves as 'customers’ -- it’s just a transaction. They give us money, we give them a product or service, end of story. Spare me the dating or marriage metaphors -- these folks don’t have, and probably never will have, a meaningful relationship with us.”
The customers who do respond to re-activation campaigns tend to be deal-seekers: people who were always responsive to promotions, went quiet when you stopped running them, and will go quiet again once the re-activation offer expires. You're not rebuilding a relationship. You're buying a transaction.
The Ellipsis recommendation is to apply Customer Science® with a Customer Lifetime Value model that considers the probability that each customer is still active and the ‘residual value’ remaining in the customer relationship. A customer who lapsed two years ago has an expected future value lower than that of your average active customer, and you're spending additional money to reach them. That investment has an opportunity cost — the same budget applied to active mid-tier customers, or genuine acquisition, almost always yields better returns.
There are narrow exceptions: genuine life-stage re-entry (a customer who moved abroad and has come back, say) or categories with long natural purchase cycles where "lapsed" is misleading. But these require data to identify, not a blanket reactivation campaign.
The lapsed list feels like low-hanging fruit. Usually, it isn't.
We are Ellipsis, the Loyalty Experts. We help you measure, manage and grow customer loyalty. We're here to help, please get in touch.
Related Articles
